Posted in Medical Ethics

Chimeras, Hybrids, and Interspecies Research: Politics and by Andrea L. Bonnicksen

By Andrea L. Bonnicksen

In his 2006 kingdom of the Union speech, President George W. Bush requested the U.S. Congress to ban the "most egregious abuses of clinical research," equivalent to the "creation of animal–human hybrids." The president's message echoed that of a 2004 file by means of the President's Council on Bioethics, which urged that hybrid human–animal embryos be banned by way of Congress.

Discussions of early interspecies examine, during which cells or DNA are interchanged among people and nonhumans at early levels of improvement, can usually devolve into sweeping statements, colourful imagery, and complicated coverage. even supposing latest coverage advisory teams have gotten extra expert, debate remains to be constrained via the interchangeable use of phrases resembling chimeras and hybrids, a bent to regard all types of interspecies alike, the failure to differentiate among laboratory learn and procreation, and never sufficient critical coverage justification. Andrea Bonnicksen seeks to appreciate purposes in the back of help of and disdain for interspecies study in such components as chimerism, hybridization, interspecies nuclear move, cross-species embryo move, and transgenics. She highlights claims critics make opposed to early interspecies stories: that the examine will violate human dignity and that it may possibly bring about procreation. Are those claims adequate to justify restrictive coverage?

Bonnicksen rigorously illustrates the demanding situations of constructing coverage for delicate and infrequently sensationalized research―research that touches deep-seated values and that probes the boundary among human and nonhuman animals.

Show description

Read or Download Chimeras, Hybrids, and Interspecies Research: Politics and Policymaking PDF

Best medical ethics books

The Black Stork: Eugenics and the Death of "Defective" Babies in American Medicine and Motion Pictures since 1915

Within the overdue 1910s Dr. Harry J. Haiselden, a trendy Chicago health care professional, electrified the country via permitting the deaths of no less than six babies he clinically determined as "defectives". He displayed the demise babies to reporters, wrote approximately them for the Hearst newspapers, and starred in a function movie approximately his campaign.

Medical Enhancement and Posthumanity (The International Library of Ethics, Law and Technology)

This e-book severely examines the professionals and cons of our transforming into skill to form human nature via technological developments. It systematically analyzes the ancient, conceptual and moral matters relating to clinical enhancement and posthumanity.

Reconceiving Medical Ethics (Continuum Studies in Philosophy)

This quantity of unique paintings includes a modest problem, occasionally direct, occasionally implicit, to the mainstream Anglo-American notion of the self-discipline of scientific ethics. It does so now not through attempting to fill the gaps with unique minority curiosity subject matters, yet via re-examining a few of the basic assumptions of the time-honored philosophical arguments, and a few of the fundamental occasions that generate the problems.

Additional info for Chimeras, Hybrids, and Interspecies Research: Politics and Policymaking

Sample text

Would the chimeric element make the intervention different from other nontherapeutic studies on human embryos? The HERP looked at the clinical use of human-human chimeras and regarded the transfer of human-human chimeras to a woman’s uterus to be ethically unacceptable because it would offend “deeply held beliefs about individuation and personal identity” (National Institutes of Health 1994, 95). If one regards the embryo as having the moral status of a person, then by implication the individuality argument would apply to untransferred embryos too.

In these states, early ISR is unlikely to pass muster. S. policy is a set of recommendations from a report in 2005 written by the Committee on Guidelines for Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research (hereafter Committee on Guidelines), written under the auspices of the National Research Council and Institute of Medicine. These facilities are two branches of the National Academy of Science, a nongovernmental organization charted by Congress to provide scientific advice to the Congress. In relevant part, the Committee on Guidelines recommended that institutions engaged in human ES-cell research set up ESCROs to add a layer of review beyond that provided by Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) in light of the “complex issues raised by hES cell research” (Committee on Guidelines 2005, 4).

Chimerism in humans may not be detected if the zygotes are of the same sex and no anomalies are observed. In one case a fifty-two-yearold woman with three children was told, after tests to assess whether her children could be organ donors for her, that she could not be the mother of two of the children because they did not share her HLA haplotype. People usually inherit one HLA haplotype from each parent. This woman, however, had an unknown haplotype. Further inquiry, including tests of her brother, led doctors to speculate that two fertilized eggs had fused in her mother’s uterus so she had cells in her body from four gametes.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.37 of 5 – based on 27 votes